Text of the sermon preached on Advent 3A (December 11, 2016) by the Rev. Katie Hargis at St. Cornelius’ Episcopal Church in Dodge City, KS.
What happens when our expectations don’t get met? How about when it’s our expectations about God that don’t get met?
A few years ago, Steve Johnson, a wide receiver for the Buffalo Bills, voiced his surprise on Twitter when things didn’t turn out the way he hoped during the football game. After Johnson dropped a potentially game-winning touchdown pass during overtime, the Pittsburg Steelers won the game 16-13. The New York Daily News reported that Johnson blamed God and tweeted: “I praise you 24/7!!! And this is how you do me!!! You expect me to learn from this??? How??? I’ll never forget this!! Ever!! Thx Tho.”
If your theology says that praising God causes God to reward you by favoring your football team, then what if you drop the ball?
Maybe Johnson should just be commended for the honesty of his prayer, for being in communication with God about his questions and doubts.
Maybe his expectations were not met. Either God wasn’t keeping God’s end of Steve Johnson’s deal, or Johnson’s world had just shrunk, with God operating outside the box he tried to fit God into.
Or maybe God doesn’t like Buffalo.
John the Baptist’s world had shrunk. Literally. The one who was preparing a way in the wide-open wilderness is held captive in a prison cell. The one who baptized the Son of God in the Jordan River is dependent on his jailor to bring him a cup of cold water to drink. The one who was so sure of who Jesus was, now wonders, Are you the one who is to come? Really?
Matthew writes, “When John heard what Jesus [the Messiah] was doing…” Actually, what Matthew could have written is, “When John heard what the Messiah was not doing…”
Jesus was not following John’s outline for his ministry. Jesus was not following John’s mission statement for him, his step-by-step plan for successful Messianic ministry. John had told people the axe was lying at the root, ready to chop down the unworthy trees. He had promised the chaff would burn with unquenchable fire. But Jesus didn’t seem to be pointing the finger of judgement. There was no smoldering woodpile of sinners. And this must have meant more than mild disappointment for John: He was at that very moment sitting in prison, awaiting his own beheading because he had dared to stand up and challenge King Herod for Herod’s unrighteous marriage. If Jesus were looking for some chaff worthy of burning, he could start by lighting a match to King Herod, and get John out of prison.
Instead, Jesus is pronouncing forgiveness, healing the sick, bringing Good News to the poor. Was this really what Jesus was supposed to be doing? Are you the one who is to come? Or should I hope for someone else?
Sometimes Jesus said and did some strange things, or certainly unexpected things, or things that aren’t what we hope for. And because of that, John asks, and the disciples ask, and we ask, “Are you the one who is to come, or should we look for someone else?”
Each of us has expectations about the kind of Savior we want. Some do want a brimstone and fire-breathing Messiah who points out where everyone else is going wrong. Some of us want a Jesus who will champion our favorite cause, who will assure us that God is on our side of the issue.
Or maybe we want a gentle shepherd who will not demand anything of us, but only assure us that he loves us.
Sooner or late, though, our ideas of Jesus bump up against reports of what he is doing, either in Scripture or the world. Jesus — the real Jesus, the real Messiah, Lord, Shepherd, Savior, Friend, Redeemer — will at times upset our expectations. And he will ask, “Do you want to follow the living Christ, or do you want to worship your idea of who he should be? Do you want the thrill and hope and challenge of a life with the living Christ? Or merely the comfort of worshipping an idol of your own making?”
John wondered if Jesus was really the one in whom he should hope. So he went to Jesus to ask. John couldn’t get there in person, so he sent his disciples. But John went to the source instead of just muddling along, or making assumptions, or staying in the dark about who Jesus is.
We are invited to do the same — go to Jesus with our questions, concerns, wondering. Participate in the ways Jesus has given to his church to know him better. Gather in community. Study with other Christians and wonderers. Pray. Take communion. Worship. Praise him — even when you drop the ball.
Maybe Jesus wasn’t exactly what John was expecting: He brought fire — but it was the fire of the Holy Spirit. He sought out sinners — and forgave them. He really let the unworthy have it — but what he let them have was grace. Grace upon grace.
John couldn’t see it for himself, locked away in his prison cell, so he asked; and in reply, he received a beautiful vision: “The blind receive their sight, the lame walk, the lepers are cleansed, the deaf hear, the dead are raised, and the poor have good news bought to them.”